I came across a client machine where, whenever he Hibernated the computer, it ends up in shutting down the machine. What used to happen was that he first used the Hibernate option. Then while switching back on, the computer would get stuck on the start-up screen and finally turn off the machine, loosing all the saved data.
So I had some idea on how to approach this issue. First one needs to check one’s Power Plan because I have experienced before, that a corrupted power plan can cause strange issues with Windows Sleep, Shutdown, etc. So first I decided to delete the power plan, since he was using a custom power plan I had created for him. Remember if you’re following this you cannot delete the standard power plans - you can only just reset the plans to default settings – which you should!
Hibernate shuts down computer
So I opened Control Panel\All Control Panel Items\Power Options\Edit Plan Settings. You can also just click on the Battery icon in the notification area and click on More options.
Next select the power plan you created and use and click on Delete this plan. Now use one of the built-in standard Power Plan and see if the problem goes away.
Unfortunately I had the same problem, so I decided to reboot the system in Selective Startup. In Windows 8, to disable or manage startup programs, you have to open Task Manager and click on the Startup tab. Here you can see the list and right-click on any entry to Disable it.
So I disabled all non-Microsoft related items except the drivers and rebooted. But I still had the same problem.
So finally I thought that it might be a driver related problem, since most of the times, the Sleep or Hibernate related issues are related to Display drivers. My client was using nVidia driver card. Lucky I found a driver that is released for Windows 8.1. So first I uninstalled the current driver, rebooted and then installed the newly downloaded drivers. Once it was installed, I rebooted again.
Then I found out there was also a BIOS update available for his Laptop model (It was a Samsung Laptop). So I updated that as well.
Now I tried to Hibernate and voilà it worked. So it’s either the Power Plan or Display drivers or the BIOS update that may help you fix this problem. I’m still not sure which one. So in case if you’re ever experiencing this problem I hope my steps will help you troubleshoot the problem.