Windows 10 free Upgrade Policy confuses some and disappoints others

An unusual move from Microsoft Corp. left many genuine users of the Windows OS surprised as the company came clear on its Windows 10 free upgrade policy. Yes, Microsoft clarified people running pirated versions of Windows will also get the free Windows upgrade to version 10 alongside the genuine users – and not just in China, but worldwide!

windows-10-blue-logo

The decision taken by the software giant comes close on the grounds of piracy issues. Microsoft has long struggled with piracy issues especially, in China. Former CEO, Steve Ballmer had revealed that Microsoft’s revenue in China represented only 5% of sales in the US, implying that much of its software in China was pirated and unlicensed. Although, Windows 8 demand has been lacklustre, the OS continues to remain one of Microsoft’s core revenue generators.

To overcome this, the tech bigwig decided to offer free upgrade from a non-genuine version of Windows 7 or Windows 8.1. The idea behind this is to basically get all Windows users on the same common base.

Having said that, it should be noted though non-Genuine PCs may be able to upgraded to Windows 10, the upgrade will not change the genuine state of the license. So, if you are running a pirated version of Windows, you’ll essentially be upgrading to a non-authorized version of Windows 10.

This is confusing. What does this mean? So will a pirated Windows user be able to upgrade to Windows 10 – but since his Windows 10 does not get activated, he will not be eligible to get further security or feature updates? This is what is being currently understood by me.

Windows 10 free upgrade policy

With Windows 10, although non-genuine PCs may be able to upgrade to Windows 10, the upgrade will not change the genuine state of the license. Non-genuine Windows is not activated by Microsoft. It is not properly licensed, or supported by Microsoft or a trusted partner. If a device was considered non-genuine prior to the upgrade, that device will continue to be considered non-genuine after the upgrade, said the Microsoft spokesperson.

Read: Making sense of Microsoft’s free Windows 10 upgrade strategy.

As Microsoft describes the situation on its Genuine Windows page, you’ll may frequent messages, warning you that your copy of Windows may not be genuine. Your desktop could turn to black. You can reset it, but it will continue to turn black periodically, until you activate Windows. All your applications may still be able to function, but you may not be able to update your Windows 10 computer further to get critical security updates or updates which add features to the operating system.

The latest move from Microsoft of upgrading pirated versions to legitimate versions of Windows 10 makes sense in a way.

It can help expand Windows user base and get all Windows users on to a common base platform, which will allow Microsoft to widen its ecosystem with applications such as Cortana, Spartan, Office 365, Azure and more. This way, instead of charging an upfront fee for the operating system, Microsoft covers an alternative way for generating revenue in more passive ways, like Bing search along with subscriptions to Office and Windows as well.

The obvious fallout of Microsoft’s plan is that this disappoints all those genuine Windows users, who had paid for the operating system. Now with this step, even users with pirated versions of Windows, will come onto the common base.

This is of course based on the understanding of the declared intent today. The earlier Microsoft clears the air, the better.

You thoughts and inputs would be most appreciated!

Posted by on , in Category Windows with Tags
Anand Khanse is the Admin of TheWindowsClub.com, a 10-year Microsoft MVP Awardee in Windows (2006-16) & a Windows Insider MVP. Please read the entire post & the comments first, create a System Restore Point before making any changes to your system & be careful about any 3rd-party offers while installing freeware.

3 Comments

  1. Russ Soule

    this is a business decision that Microsoft is entitled to make, without a lot of “back-seat driving” opinions from the blogasphere. would I have done it if I were running Microsoft? most likely not since it WILL impact the profits. however, the long view is that “free” opsys is the most likely method of running computers in the near and distant future, so Microsoft is merely jumping on the long-view bandwagon.

  2. ErnieK

    My first thought when I read that MS was also giving the free upgrade to piratednon-genuine installations of Windows was that this would give some folks the chance to start using the genuine article. Now I begin to wonder.

    If someone with a pirated version of windows does upgrade this would send information to MS giving the details of the pirated version and also the IP address of the users. After trying to go genuine the individuals would still be in the situation of having a non-registered installation. In other words no incentive. Plus MS would then have the relevant details to catch these users. Some of these users use ilegal OS because they think that it is thier right and some use it because they cannot afford to purchase the legal version and it these folks [second example] who would be put at a disadvantage.

    This offer to them is self defeating. Who in there right mind would take a fully working [illegal] OS and upgrade to a version that is crippled in someway? MS would also [IMO] make it impossible to revert back to using the old [illegal] OS. MS has to either give the free upgrade to illegal user, no matter how much it would grate with me after paying for all my OS’s, and make them legal or there would be no incentive for these illegal user to carry out the upgrade. Users of these illegal Windows 7 installations are getting, as far as I understand, the MS security updates and will do so for the next 4-5 years therefor why upgrade to one that will not, and will within a short period of time, be insecure,

    The above is just my thoughts and I am NOT defending those illegal users.

  3. Zoltar

    In my opinion: if Microsoft wants everyone on Windows 10, just give away legal copies for free. Just think; the cost of a new PC, notebook, tablet, etc. would drop dramatically if the price for the OS license was excluded from the OEM cost.

    Another argument could be that the consumer should not have to pay for an OS that contains all the latest NSA control and snooping technologies. Courtesy of your friend, the US government.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


2 + 7 =